Content
From Vaudeville Footlights to Integrated Storytelling
The roots of the Broadway musical are tangled and diverse, drawing from various forms of popular entertainment. European operetta, with its lighthearted plots and memorable tunes, certainly played a part. Minstrel shows, despite their deeply problematic history, contributed elements of song, dance, and sketch comedy structure. Vaudeville, a variety show format featuring singers, dancers, comedians, and novelty acts, was perhaps the most direct ancestor, providing the talent pool and the audience appetite for spectacular entertainment. Early shows often felt like collections of songs and routines loosely strung together by a flimsy plot – entertainment first, cohesive story second. Shows like Jerome Kern’s Show Boat (1927), with lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II, marked a significant turning point. It dared to tackle serious themes like racism and marital struggle, weaving its songs more directly into the narrative fabric than most predecessors. It wasn’t just a collection of tunes; the music served the story, deepening character and advancing the plot. This integration became the hallmark of what many consider the “Golden Age” of musical theatre.The Golden Age: Crafting the Classics
The period roughly spanning the 1940s to the late 1960s saw the form truly blossom. This era was dominated by legendary partnerships, none more influential than Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II. Starting with Oklahoma! (1943), they revolutionized the musical. The story came first, and every element – song, dance, dialogue – served to illuminate that story and its characters. The opening number wasn’t a flashy chorus line but a lone cowboy singing about the beautiful morning. Agnes de Mille’s groundbreaking choreography wasn’t mere decoration; her “dream ballet” explored the protagonist Laurey’s subconscious fears and desires. Rodgers and Hammerstein followed this triumph with a string of enduring classics: Carousel, South Pacific, The King and I, and The Sound of Music. Their work set a high bar for dramatic coherence and emotional depth. Other titans of the era included Lerner and Loewe (My Fair Lady, Camelot), Frank Loesser (Guys and Dolls, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying), and Jule Styne (Gypsy, Funny Girl). These shows solidified the structure many still associate with classic musicals: a well-crafted book (the script or libretto), songs that revealed character (“I Want” songs, soliloquies) or moved the plot, and dance that either expressed joy, created spectacle, or externalized internal conflict. Jerome Robbins’ electrifying choreography for West Side Story (1957), with Leonard Bernstein’s complex score and Stephen Sondheim’s sharp lyrics, showcased how dance could be a primary storytelling language, depicting gang warfare and soaring romance with visceral energy.Changing Times, Evolving Forms
The late 1960s and 1970s brought significant social and cultural upheaval, and musical theatre reflected these changes. The integrated book musical wasn’t abandoned, but new forms emerged. The “concept musical,” often associated with director Hal Prince and composer-lyricist Stephen Sondheim, gained prominence. Shows like Company (1970) and Follies (1971) prioritized theme and idea over linear plot, exploring modern relationships, memory, and disillusionment through innovative structures and musically sophisticated scores. Rock music, which had exploded in popular culture, found its way to the Broadway stage. Hair (1968), with its tribal rock score and counter-culture themes, broke new ground. It was followed by other rock-infused shows like Jesus Christ Superstar and Godspell. Dance also evolved, with figures like Bob Fosse developing a distinctively slinky, cynical, and influential style seen in shows like Pippin (1972), Chicago (1975), and his own revue, Dancin’.The Integration is Key: A defining characteristic of the most successful and enduring musicals, particularly from the Golden Age onward, is the seamless integration of book, music, and lyrics. Each element works in concert with the others to propel the narrative, develop characters, and evoke emotion. When done well, a song or dance sequence feels inevitable, the only way a character could possibly express that specific moment.The 1980s were marked by the arrival of the “mega-musical,” often imported from London’s West End. Andrew Lloyd Webber (Cats, The Phantom of the Opera) and the team of Alain Boublil and Claude-Michel Schönberg (Les Misérables, Miss Saigon) dominated the decade with epic productions characterized by sweeping scores, elaborate stagecraft, and often, sung-through narratives with little spoken dialogue. These shows became global phenomena, emphasizing spectacle and powerful, if sometimes broadly drawn, emotion.
Contemporary Broadway: A Diverse Landscape
Broadway today is a vibrant, eclectic mix. The legacy of the Golden Age endures in revivals and new works inspired by its principles. Concept musicals continue to push boundaries. Rock and pop music are fully integrated, powering shows from Rent (1996), which captured the anxieties and aspirations of a generation, to the biographical jukebox musicals celebrating the catalogues of famous artists. Movie adaptations have become a significant trend, translating popular films like The Lion King, Wicked (based on a novel inspired by a film), and Frozen into stage extravaganzas. These often bring built-in audience recognition but face the challenge of justifying their existence as live theatre. Perhaps the most significant recent phenomenon was Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Hamilton (2015). Its use of hip-hop, jazz, R&B, and traditional show tunes to tell the story of America’s founding fathers revitalized the form, attracting new audiences and demonstrating the musical’s capacity for telling diverse stories in innovative ways. It underscored a growing commitment, albeit one still evolving, towards greater diversity in storytelling, casting, and creative teams.The Essential Ingredients
Music: The Heartbeat of the Show
Music is the engine of the musical. It establishes mood, conveys emotion more directly than words alone, reveals character psychology, and drives the plot. Composers use melody, harmony, rhythm, and instrumentation to create the sonic world of the show. Lyrics, crafted by the lyricist (sometimes the same person as the composer or book writer), must not only rhyme and fit the music but also sound like the authentic voice of the character singing them. Songs serve various functions: the “I Want” song expresses a character’s primary goal, ballads explore love or loss, charm songs delight, and big chorus numbers provide energy and spectacle while often advancing the plot or establishing the community.Dance: Storytelling Through Movement
In a musical, dance is rarely just decorative. Great choreographers use movement as a powerful storytelling tool. Dance can express emotions too overwhelming for words – joy, grief, passion, rage. It can establish character, reveal relationships, depict conflict, or create stunning visual metaphors. From Agnes de Mille’s character-driven ballets and Jerome Robbins’ explosive street dances to Bob Fosse’s stylized sensuality and Andy Blankenbuehler’s intricate, narrative-rich work in Hamilton and In the Heights, choreography shapes our understanding of the story and its inhabitants. The ensemble, often seen as the backbone of a musical, frequently uses dance to represent the community, societal forces, or the energy of a particular setting.The Book: The Narrative Spine
While song and dance often get the spotlight, a strong “book” or libretto is crucial. The book writer crafts the dialogue, shapes the plot structure, and ensures the story flows logically and emotionally. A key challenge is managing the transitions between spoken scenes and musical numbers so they feel organic, not jarring. The book provides the context, the character arcs, and the dramatic stakes that give the songs and dances their meaning and impact. Without a solid narrative foundation, even the most brilliant score or dazzling choreography can feel hollow.Stagecraft: Creating the World
The visual elements – sets, costumes, lighting – are vital collaborators in the storytelling. Scenic design creates the physical world, transporting the audience to different times and places, from realistic settings to abstract landscapes. Costumes define character, indicating period, social status, personality, and sometimes symbolic meaning. Lighting shapes mood, focuses attention, creates atmosphere, and guides the audience’s eye. Together, these design elements create the immersive experience that makes live theatre so compelling.The Magic is Live: Remember that recordings and film adaptations, while valuable, cannot fully replicate the unique energy of a live Broadway performance. The shared experience in the theatre, the connection between performers and audience, and the immediacy of the music and movement create a distinct and often electrifying atmosphere. It’s a communal event built on presence.
